Dec
06
Filed Under (Uncategorized) by Mani Karthik on 06-12-2006


Forums are unanimously selected by webmasters when looking for creating Niche websites with stickyness.

Forums are helpful in creating communities that enable users to visit your website every other time thereby increasing traffic.So the uses of forums are numerous - easy to use, easy to install, and easy end user experience.

One question always asked among web designers is - Which is the best forum pack for a website?


And interestingly, although people have differences in opinion, they agree on one thing - the decision should be based on your usage type and not a result of band wagon effect.

There are various packages around, some of the most popular ones used are PhpBB, VBulletin and SMF.

All the three are different in many aspects though are similar in function - being forums.

Some of them are paid ones, with customer support and hacker protection, while some are free and easy to use - and favourties of hackers. Some go in between.

To help web masters decide on the best forum package for their site, I’ve listed the various forum packs with their features and a comparison list on who has it and who doesn’t. It would give you an easy flowchart kind of reference as to - If i need “this” then, “this” is best and “that” is not.

Feature

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Author

Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

The phpBB Group

Invision Power Services

SMF Development Team

URL

www.vbulletin.com

www.phpbb.com

www.invisionpower.com

www.simplemachines.org

Free or Open Source

No

Yes

No

Yes

License

commercial / visible source

GPL

Commercial

Custom

License cost

$160 owned or $85/year

0

Perpetual $185.00 Yearly $69.95

0

Programming Language

PHP

PHP

PHP 4.3+

PHP

UTF-8 Support

Yes

No

Yes

Type

Threaded or Flat

Flat

Threaded or Flat

Flat

Data Storage

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

MySQL

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Postgres

No

Yes

No

No

Oracle

No

No

Yes

No

SQLite

No

No

No

Texfiles

No

No

No

other

MS SQL 7/2000, MS Access

MS SQL

Hosting available

No

Posts

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

BBCode

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

HTML

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Emoticons

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Formatting Toolbar

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

WYSIWYG Editor

Yes

Yes

No

Quoting

Single

Nested

Nested

Nested

Syntax Highlighting

Yes

Yes

Yes

Attachments

Multiple files

No

Multiple files

Multiple files

Forums

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Categories

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Subforums

unlimited

No

unlimited

unlimited

Last Post

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Redirect Forums

Yes

No

Yes

Plugin

Trashcan Forum

Yes

No

Optional

Yes

Notification

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

RSS/ATOM

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

E-Mail

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Instant Messaging

0

0

Bookmarks

Yes

No

Yes

Community

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Avatars

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

User Ranks

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Rating/Karma System

Yes

Yes

Yes

Signatures

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Users Online List

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Private Messaging

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Custom profile fields

Yes

No

Yes

Plugin

Moderation

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Moderators

global and forums

global and forums

global, forums and threads

global, forums and threads

Move Threads

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Split Threads

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Close Threads

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Shadow Topics

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Sticky Threads

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Important Threads

Yes

Yes

Yes

Search

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Full-text search

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Author search

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Advanced search

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Unread Topics

Database tracked

Customization

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Languages

Official: English, German, Chinese, Hungarian; Translatable into any language

50+

Integrated language editor

25+

Templates

global and forum specific

global

global

global and forum specific

Custom BBCodes

Yes

No

Yes

Plugin

Skin-Editor

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Smiley Packs

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Plugins

Yes

Optional

Yes

Special Features

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Statistics

Yes

Yes

Yes

Polls

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Calendar

Yes

Patch

Yes

Yes

Friendly URLs

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Anti-Spam and Security

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

CAPTCHA

Yes

Yes

Yes

Plugin

Groups

Multiple groups

Multiple groups

Multiple groups

Multiple groups

Flood Control

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

ACLs

Yes

Yes

Yes

Blacklist

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Warnings

Yes

No

Yes

lugin

Suspension

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Bans

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

IP-Block

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Data Management

vBulletin

phpBB

Invision Power Board

SMF

Pruning

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Archiving

No

No

Yes

Export Formats

Single Table CSV, Single and Multi-Table SQL

Word, HTML

WAP(2), IMode

Export private messages

Yes

No

Yes

No

Lo-Fi View

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

This comparison chart can also be foud here

To conclude, many webmasters prefers phpBB as the best open source hosting package - but it has the following downs.
- Security issues
- Does not give your site that professional look
- Everybody knows it’s a cheap one.

But it scores in the following points.
- Has plenty of plugins and hacks available that makes it unique.
- Plenty of skins available.
- Can be integrated easily with other php based packages like image galleries.

But many webmasters prefer VBulletin if you are going for a professional website(that is if you can pay for it.)
Up’s
- Excellent security
- Good client support
Downs
- The money factor of course!
- not many plugins and hacks available as phpbb.

Hope this helped in understanding which forum to go with on your site.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

    Read More   

Comments

gennnniiikk on 6 October, 2007 at 7:05 pm #

Hello

Bye


idnedhelper on 7 November, 2007 at 11:44 am #

Hi,

Can you explain me how to create new poll on this forum. Thanks :)


Mani Karthik on 7 November, 2007 at 9:56 pm #

You can find it here


idnedhelper on 11 November, 2007 at 4:56 am #

Holla,

Can you explain me how to create new poll on this forum. Thanks :)


fluennafuts9 on 14 November, 2007 at 11:12 am #

Incoming links to this article

Post a Comment
Name:
Email:
Website:
Comments:

When commenting on this blog it will automatically find your blog's (if you have one) latest post and link to it.