First off a clarification. Links aren’t everything that can get you higher ranks on Google.Yes, links can be the most weighed metric, but it definitely is not the single thing that will help you get ranks.

Somehow, there are many people who are adamant to believe that links are everything. These days, webmasters are very particular about link building and some of them have even collected some dirt and dust in the whole process that it annoys you.

By dirt and dust I meant some common misconceptions about link building. Here goes.

(These ideas were collected from numerous “SEO gurus” who claimed that they are “Link building experts” on a couple of Google groups.)

- Getting as many links as possible to my site puts me higher than someone else on the SERPs.
- Directory submission is the secret weapon.
- A three way link exchange is the wise mans tool to reap links.
- Get links from “themed” sites it helps you rank better.

It is unfortunate to know that many SEO’s agree to the above and in rare cases even get confused.

- Getting as many links as possible to my site puts me higher than someone else on the SERPs.

Completely wrong. Aaron Wall might have referred something along these lines in his SEO book (which was released years earlier mind you.), but that doesn’t mean you have to follow it in these times of SEO 2.0

Sure the volume of links are a great metric that will push you forward but, more than the number it’s the quality that matters. 100 links from different directories is not good while 10 contextual links from blogs can cut the competition.

- Directory submission is the secret weapon.

Did you know that Google keeps an eye on the most popular directories and keeps them off the authority brackets? Aaron did not mention it in his book, as a matter of fact. Directory submissions are only a push factor to your ranks. I think a well crafted mix of backlinks from some real good contextual text and some “respected” directories will make it an irresistible combo while backlinks from directories alone is futile. 

- A three way link exchange is the wise mans tool to reap links.

Last day I got contacted by a link building expert on chat. He asked me if I had a PR4 website, I said yes and he demanded the URL (To test if it’s really PR4). On approval he told me that he’ll give me a backlink for which I have to reciprocate another. I denied. He offered me two links for one. I denied again to which he replied - “OK, I’ll give you 3 links”. On denial again he got frustrated. He asks - “Why? I’m giving you three links from different sites and that also theme based !! You won’t get a better offer than this.” :-p

The funda was that he had a network of websites in his belt and every time someone offers a link he goes for a three way link exchange.

Three way (or for that matter any link exchanges) will not work. They are simply a waste of time.

- Get links from “themed” sites it helps you rank better.
Sure it does. But what is the meaning of themed websites? One version is that websites which belong to the same category as your’s are themed websites.

Perfect! It is true that getting links from a site that is similar in content to your’s make sense. But I believe the “theme” thingy should come down to a more refined level. You should talk about the paragraph of text surrounding your link to the “themed”, the keyword proximity and keyword density is what should make your link themed. So, rather than finding a site based on it’s category as listed in the blog directory, it makes more sense to hunt links in similar or related content.

So there you go. Getting links to your site is not a mechanical process, it’s largely natural. As the SEO 2.0(more on that in the next posts) rule goes, a compelling content is your biggest link bait. And of course you can cement together your site strength with other factors such as directory submissions and link building etc. But solely relying on artificial methods to link building is retarded.

Related SEO Tips and Articles:

  1. Nice article, Mani. I strongly agree with everything except the 3-way linking, which I strongly disagree.

    I’ve done quite a bit of 3-way linking and seen some excellent results.

    Off-theme links still count, good points there.

    Josh Spaulding’s last blog post..EveryonesArticles.com Up for Sale

    [Reply to this comment]

  2. mani, yes three way linking does seem to help…am not sure how google can find a three way link as not natural…but contextual links are the best as they are the most natural links and you are spot on…

    Techblissonline Dot Com’s last blog post..Registry virtualization, Disk Cleanup, Disk Defragmenter, System Restore and registry cleaner in windows vista

    [Reply to this comment]

  3. Josh, I find that many three way links are a big compromise on the quality..Many a times a third site is added just because you don’t want an exchange. If you can get a great three way exchange, why waste time? For the same effort, you could get a one way link. Which I think makes more sense.

    The idea of three way link is great but when it comes to implementation, it’s often a big compromise.

    But hey, I may be wrong.

    [Reply to this comment]

  4. Hey Mani,

    Hope you remember me, we met from SEOMOZ!

    Just clarify a point in 3 way link building, It does help, in some projects client’s doesn’t agree to participate in Reciprocal, especially with big brands, so we have to have a 3 way link campaign. In Google’s Eye, I it is still a One Way link!

    Watsay?

    Catch_aj’s last blog post..Official Google Blog: Global marketing challenge now underway

    [Reply to this comment]

  5. I must say, i totally agree with you on this one Mani. Whilst links are important, they arnt everything. I no longer take part in link exchanges etc; the only link building method i use is write articles which i then distribute through various article submission sites.

    People can then download your article and use it on their sites with a link back to my site, getting me a one way link from an article which is related to my websites topic.

    I think its very important that any link building methods you do take part in, must be on topic. 1 link from a website which is related to your topic, is worth 5 links from unrelated websites.

    Andy MacDonald - Marketing & SEO Blog’s last blog post..Boosting your blog with better content

    [Reply to this comment]

    Mani KarthikNo Gravatar Replied:

    I can’t think of anything to disagree with you Andy. You are spot on! :)

    [Reply to this comment]

  6. Interesting post, I’ll keep this in mind.

    -Mike

    Mike Huang’s last blog post..Guest Posting’s True Infinite Power

    [Reply to this comment]

  7. I have used backlinks to a few of my sites and have found them invaluable if somewhat timeconsuming to set up.

    [Reply to this comment]